So so so under it. But did you see Laura Quinney's piece on Louise Glück in the LRB? A thorough trouncing, but with the plausible deniability endemic to poetry reviews. Oh, if only more poetry reviewers would enjoy their judgments enough to make them sing.

UPDATE: Redacted a name and an uncalled-for implication that only the bearer of that name was offering straight-up criticism. There's lots of us speaking our minds, no need to bait bears.